On the Waterfront: traitor vs. whistleblower

The film On the Waterfront explores the idea that even though one wants to stand up against improper conduct, they are hindered by the ethicality of this action, torn between whether they might be committing betrayal or following their individual beliefs of right versus wrong. Though Johnny Friendly and the mob are responsible for many murders, Terry is hesitant to testify against them, afraid of how they would respond. Terry does not want to be looked down upon as the traitor against the mob, especially since no one else has been before. The whole society has always feared telling honestly about the mob's crimes, even though many are witnesses. Meanwhile, the priest tries to convince everyone that unless someone stands up against the mob, the world will ever change and only acquire more evil. He remains firm in his stance, acknowledging the need for a change. Edie also believes in standing up for what's right, for she obviously desires an explanation for her brother's death. She now realizes that mob's crimes and no one's willingness to testify cannot continue. Though Terry wants to tell the truth in the interest of society, he also has an inclination to stay back for the sake of his own well-being.

I believe Terry definitely took the right action by telling the truth because society became stronger as a whole. One is never a traitor if they are helping a bigger cause and betraying someone who always does terrible things, for they don't deserve to be supported. Ultimately, the difference between a traitor and a whistle blower is who is being affected by the action. If only oneself or a few people come out better, they might be a traitor to whoever they left behind. But if one helps out the larger picture of society by telling the truth, then they can be considered a whistle blower who knows good ethics. Terry is justified in his decision to testify because all the other dockworkers stood up to Johnny Friendly, who was seen for who he really was: a powerful man with no true power. One must be considerate of who they would be affecting with their decision: just themself or society.

~ Question #2
.